Luis accidentally hits Isabella's car, knocking out her tail light, and quickly drives away thinking he got away with it. But problems arise for him when Greg tells Luis he saw the whole thing and pressures Luis into telling Isabella the truth. Greg is shocked when Luis refuses to fess up, and Luis' behavior only gets worse when Isabella comes into the donut shop reeling about getting a ticket for her broken tail light. Feeling bad for Isabella, combined with the stress of knowing Luis did it is too much for Greg and he confesses to Isabella he saw Luis hit her car. But much to Greg's surprise, he doesn't come out smelling like a rose.